| Preview | Description
  | Artist | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Falstaff Playing King by George Whiting Flagg 1836 New York Historical Society New York, NY | Flagg, George Whiting | |
 | Falstaff Playing King (1) by George Whiting Flagg ca. 1834 New York Historical Society New York, NY | Flagg, George Whiting | |
 | Fannie Fredericka Dyckman And Mary Alice Dyckman by Henry Augustus Loop 1876 New York Historical Society New York, NY | Loop, Henry Augustus |  Fannie and Mary Alice Dyckman were daughters of Isaac Michael and Fannie Blackwell (Brown) Dyckman. They gave Dyckman House in upper Manhattan to the City of New York, which has preserved it as an historic landmark. Fannie (pictured at right) later married the architect Alexander McMillan Welch; Mary Alice later married Bashford Dean, the noted... |
 | Four Studies Of Heads In Profile by James Edward Freeman 1842 New York Historical Society New York, NY | Freeman, James Edward | John F. McGuigan, Jr., a James Edward Freeman scholar, makes the following identification of the caricatures. Center figure: Frederick Fink Top left: Luther Terry Bottom figure: possibly Thomas Cole Bottom Left: unidentified. Albany Institute has similar caricature sketches by Cole. |
 | Francis A. Hall by Frederick R. Spencer 1857 New York Historical Society New York, NY | Spencer, Frederick R. | The subject was the son of John Bishop Hall and Evelina (McFarlan) Hall of New York. His portrait was a gift to the Society from his cousins. |
 | Francis Robert Schell by Henry Peters Gray ca. 1855-1860 New York Historical Society New York, NY | Gray, Henry Peters | |
 | Garret Rapalje by John Durand 1768 New York Historical Society New York, NY | Durand, John | |
 | General Winfield Scott by Alonzo Chappel ca. 1850 New York Historical Society New York, NY | Chappel, Alonzo | |
 | George Opdyke by Frederick R. Spencer oil on linen New York Historical Society New York, NY | Spencer, Frederick R. | George Opdyke (1805 - June 12, 1880) was an entrepreneur, a millionaire, and the Mayor of New York during the American Civil War, from 1862 to 1863 |
 | George Washington by Archibald Robertson 1791 New York Historical Society New York, NY | Robertson, Archibald |
- New York Historical Society
