the subject, died 1832; his granddaughter, Emily Caton MacTavish, 1832– died 1867; her granddaughter, Emily MacTavish, by 1867; her mother, Mrs. Charles Carroll MacTavish, Sr., custodian, deposited at the Maryland Historical Society, 1892–1912; her daughter, Virginia Scott MacTavish, Rome, by 1912; her brother, Charles Carroll MacTavish, Jr., 1919–1948; his cousin, Charles Bancroft Carroll, New York, 1948– ca. 1955; Newport, R. I., art market, 1955–1956